National Gun Forum banner
1 - 4 of 4 Posts

· Registered
8,663 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
  • San Diego's Smart Streetlight cameras could get a sole user: the Police Department.
  • A new proposal, if adopted, would mark a shift in how the cameras are used.
No more collecting data on bicycles or traffic patterns, no more collecting data on humidity or weather.
The new plan calls for the few thousand cameras tucked in streetlights around the city to record video solely for police.
- On Wednesday, a City Council committee will get its first look at a plan that calls for handing off the Smart Streetlights program to police.
The plan could cost up to about $7 million over the next four years.
The proposal was laid out in a staff report to be heard by the Public Safety & Livable Neighborhoods Committee.
- The city's Sustainability Department runs the streetlight cameras program. In the staff report, department leaders pitched the change.
It comes as they seek approval to alter city contracts with Ubicquia, the company that provides the services for the Smart Streetlights program.

The reason behind the change: the cost of the mobility data collection outweighs the benefits for a city facing "financial limitations."
- Under the proposal, the Sustainability Department would turn over the program to the Police Department, which wants to keep the cameras to keep rolling. The burden of paying for it would shift to police.

  • The streetlight-mounted cameras have special sensor used to turn images of cars and people into data — thus the "smart" in smart streetlights.
  • A police official said Friday that maintaining access to the raw camera footage is a priority, and the return on investment for the department to keep the cameras rolling (without the sensors) "far exceeds" the cost.
  • Police first accessed the camera footage in August 2018. As of Thursday — a little more than two years later — they had accessed footage for the 400th time.

- "They will not be 'smart' anything; they will simply be 'big brother' surveillance cameras," Geneviéve Jones-Wright, who leads a coalition of groups concerned about policing, said in a email.

She called the timing of the proposal "tone deaf."

"Why are we seeking to commit $7 million more dollars to a citywide network of surveillance cameras for police use in the middle of our city’s biggest deficit and while there are so many unresolved issues surrounding police trust and accountability?" she said.

Jones-Wright also said it was "the precise wrong time" for the city to buy "a widespread mass surveillance system without ordinances that will provide oversight," which she noted her coalition is working on with council members.
  • Like
Reactions: gvaldeg1

· Registered
8,663 Posts
Discussion Starter · #2 ·
Tech-laden lamp posts are fixtures of the international “smart city” landscape; cities in Europe and Asia have rushed to install streetlights equipped with features that can monitor traffic, weather, and other urban phenomena. It’s not uncommon for them to drift into the hands of law enforcement. Fears of China’s AI-powered surveillance “panopticon” led Hong Kong’s pro-democracy protesters to topple that city’s smart streetlights during demonstrations in 2019. As U.S. cities like Baltimore; Kansas City; Bethlehem, Pennsylvania; and Portland, Maine upgraded their streetlight networks, the American Civil Liberties Union has cautioned against the “stealthy” rollout of “spying technology.”

“Rather than call them smart bulbs in smart cities, I’d call them surveillance bulbs in surveillance cities,” Chad Marlow, advocacy and policy council for the ACLU,told CityLab in 2018.

When San Diego launched its smart streetlight pilot program with GE Current in 2016, officials promised it would open up a pantheon of opportunities. Not only would the LED lights use less energy and save money, their sensors would collect air quality and mobility data. Parking would be easier, streets would be safer, and entrepreneurs would build businesses around all this open data. The pilot was extended into a full-fledged program in 2018. Under a $30 million contract, GE retrofitted 14,000 of the city’s 60,000 streetlights with LEDs, and placed sophisticated sensors on 3,200 of them — including small nodes that captured video.

I knew there are cameras everywhere. But. This is my first encounter with this development.

· Registered
4,756 Posts
Big Brother is coming folks, Big Brother is coming...............................
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.