National Gun Forum banner

Ruger or Savage?

1725 Views 17 Replies 8 Participants Last post by  deputy
I will be buying a new rifle and have narrowed it down to the savage 116 bear hunter and the ruger go wild camo both chambered in .300 win mag. If you had to choose between these two rifles which one would you choose?
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
What will you be using it for?
I agree with Mad Scientist in first asking what you intend to do with it, but based on your other posts, I suspect you intend hunting with it. Based on my knowledge of Ruger American rifles and Savage 110 rifles, I would choose the Savage first off because the 110 is not an entry level rifle like the American is. The 110 stock has an aluminum bedding system which works quite well in my opinion and is superior to the Ruger American stock. The Savage can also be adjusted to fit you, though I have never had a rifle with that set-up. Both rifles are equipped with muzzle brakes which make them insanely loud, even for a 300 win mag. Both have reasonable out of the box triggers, but I prefer the Savage Accutrigger over the Ruger again. If by chance you are considering dangerous game, I would again lean toward the Savage with hinged floorplate in favor of a detachable mag; magazines have known to become unseated at the worst of times. There is a reduction in capacity with the Savage (2 vs 3 in the Ruger), but security is most important here in my opinion. On the down side, the Savage is 1.5 pounds heavier; a drag carrying in the field, but a plus for recoil.

In in case you are wondering, I do own a Savage 110 and a Ruger American. If your options were between the Ruger American and a Savage Axis II, I would likely lean towards the Ruger as being a little (very little) better stock in entry level rifles, but like I said, the Savage 110 is a cut above entry level rifles...and I guess you noticed the price is also higher.
See less See more
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I have a Ruger American in 30-06. Good for any big game in North America. I have a Savage 110 in .243, my go-to deer gun.
the Savage....because the 110 is not an entry level rifle like the American is.
this.........
  • Like
Reactions: 1
whitetail deer
A .300WM rifle/ammo is overkill for hunting whitetail deer. You would be better off with a .30-06
  • Like
Reactions: 2
^^^^^ My sentiments as well.
  • Like
Reactions: 1
Or a .308 but if you want to get all new age cool look at a 6.5 Creedmoor.
The Savage 110 is the better rifle of the two. A muzzle brake is unnecessary unless one is extremely recoil sensitive.

.300 Win Mag is overkill when hunting whitetail deer. Its just too much unless you're hunting those prehistoric dinosaur whitetail deer. I use a .300 Win Mag when hunting elk at ranges in excess of 300 yards. I believe better caliber choices are:

.30-06 Spg
.308 Win
.35 Rem
.30-30 Win
7mm Mauser
6.5x55mm Swede
  • Like
Reactions: 4
Or a .308 but if you want to get all new age cool look at a 6.5 Creedmoor.
I already have a rifle chambered in 6.5 Creedmoor
300 win mag is a bit over kill for white tail like mentioned. How far do you expect to be shooting them from? The rifle calibers Popeye mention will do the job exceptionally well and then some.
Or a .308 but if you want to get all new age cool look at a 6.5 Creedmoor.
“New age cool?” Really? :rolleyes5:
I already have a rifle chambered in 6.5 Creedmoor
The Creedmore will do white tails just fine, so I suppose you just want a .300 win mag? It is overkill on Bambi, but he really won’t know the difference. I would lose the brake though unless you plan on destroying your ears... It is your choice, your money, and you will spend a few bucks more shooting .300 mag.:thumbsup:
I'll stick with my remingtons. In 30.06 :cornut: But will probably use my Ruger super blackhawk. Unless i see a further off shot.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I have harvested deer in the past with the .300 wing mag and I really like the .300 win mag. But perhaps a Thompson center pro hunter encore chambered in 30-06 wouldn’t be a bad idea.
  • Like
Reactions: 2
I have harvested deer in the past with the .300 wing mag and I really like the .300 win mag. But perhaps a Thompson center pro hunter encore chambered in 30-06 wouldn’t be a bad idea.
Perhaps. 30-06 is quite capable, and a lot less costly to shoot.
i am going to go slightly off-topic a bit on the magnums..........and tell a story........

Some years back, i knew an accomplished hunter. He owned many guns including one of every "classic" remington 700 that they came out with in the special runs.
His favorite was the 6.5 Swede that he hunted with all the time......His wife took the 257 roberts........

He elected to buy a new rifle/caliber for a special hunt in colorado.........a Weatherby MK V with synthetic stock and 26" barrel....7mm WBY mag......i asked him why since he was so salty with the swede. His response was it was a very limited time frame hunt, Distance unknown, shot angle unknown, oppertunities limited.....and he wanted a round that would literally penetrate to the vitals from any angle. He was a hand loader as well. He did not want to pass up a shot because of angle/presentation as there might not be a 2nd chance that day or any other day.....and the days were few.

i have no idea what the costs were of this out-of-state hunt.....but looking at it that way, i can see HIS justification for a magnum. He had the knowledge and the skills.

I do not.....and still limit my range and my shot angle as to what i am comfortable with.........
See less See more
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top