National Gun Forum banner
1 - 18 of 18 Posts

· Registered
Joined
·
9,148 Posts
Popeye is correct. But if your asking does the 26 have more felt recoil than the 19 or 17 then yes is does. The smaller the gun the more felt recoil. That is true with any gun not just Glock. More weight always has less felt recoil. Also the smaller grip makes it harder to control the recoil. Just because you have less to grab a hold of.
 

· AZHerper
Joined
·
6,352 Posts
I wrote a program a few years back that calculates recoil energy and velocity (along with muzzle energy). I'm not sure that I can past it here successfully. Anyway, here goes:

file:///F:/Gary's%20Saved%20Data/My%20Programs%20(Excel,%20etc)/General%20Programs/ballisticcalculator.html

Just copy and paste in browser. It should retrieve the HTML code. If it runs, just estimate powder weight for commercial ammo. Powder gasses contribute to recoil.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
8,212 Posts
If you are have a problem with limp wristing get yourself a tennis ball squeeze it for exercise. You are building up the fore arm muscles and grip muscles in you hands. Be sure to work out with both hands. There is no good reason to be half a pistol shooter.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,411 Posts
I wrote a program a few years back that calculates recoil energy and velocity (along with muzzle energy). I'm not sure that I can past it here successfully. Anyway, here goes:

file:///F:/Gary's%20Saved%20Data/My%20Programs%20(Excel,%20etc)/General%20Programs/ballisticcalculator.html

Just copy and paste in browser. It should retrieve the HTML code. If it runs, just estimate powder weight for commercial ammo. Powder gasses contribute to recoil.
You tried to post a file that is on your local F: drive. It made it to the post on your computer because you have access to the file. It didn't make it to the forum because it doesn't have access to the file and you don't want that.
 

· Grand Imperial Poobah
Joined
·
33,057 Posts
If you are have a problem with limp wristing get yourself a tennis ball squeeze it for exercise. You are building up the fore arm muscles and grip muscles in you hands. Be sure to work out with both hands. There is no good reason to be half a pistol shooter.

This! And if you have small hands, try using a racquetball instead.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
4,411 Posts
Would a Glock 26 be harder to limpwrist than a 19 or a 17? Seems like it would because in the smaller frame it would have more snap to it.
Not to pick on you but you asked a question. The premise of your question is incorrect but to answer it as accuratly as possible as is: No. It would be easier to limp wrist it not harder as you surmised. "Limp wristing" is the term used to describe not holding the gun firmly in place enough so the slide can function properly.

The delayed blowback needs the interaction between the two parts to function properly. One moves (the slide) and one is immobile (the frame). Limp wristing allows the frame to move thus interfereing with the relative movement of the slide. Enough movement (limp wristing) and the ejection of the spent round or chambering of the new round will not occur.

The lighter the gun -- the more felt recoil there is
The smaller the gun -- the harder it is to grip firmly.

Both of these occuring either seperatly or together increases the chances of limp wristing.

There will be no "limp wristing" phenomina with a firm grip on a compact gun that does not allow it to move. That's why I didn't agree with the premise of your question. There is no direct connection but a causal relationship.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Popeye

· Registered
Joined
·
20 Posts
Discussion Starter · #11 ·
Limp wristing a handgun has to do with the shooter's wrist and grip, not the firearm.
I understand it had to do with the grip and I also understand how it happens but from the research I have done it seems like a lot of it has to do with the gun as well. Military Arms Channel did a good vid on it showing how it is much harder if not impossible to limp wrist the heavier framed guns like the Sig and CZ he showed.
 

· Registered
Joined
·
660 Posts
I probably should add this. I own a Glock 17 and a Glock 26 and the recoil from both of them is minimal for a 9mm. Don't yet own a 19 but it falls between the 2 others in size and weight so it also wouldn't present any significant recoil. None of the 3 Glock 9mm's you mention should be a contributor to a shooting problem.
 

· Ancient Gaseous Emanation
Joined
·
57,900 Posts
I understand it had to do with the grip and I also understand how it happens but from the research I have done it seems like a lot of it has to do with the gun as well. Military Arms Channel did a good vid on it showing how it is much harder if not impossible to limp wrist the heavier framed guns like the Sig and CZ he showed.
It is possible, and often easy, to limp wrist any handgun regardless of its size or weight. Do not fall into the trap of blaming the handgun for the actions of the shooter.

Here it is explained quite accurately:

Not to pick on you but you asked a question. The premise of your question is incorrect but to answer it as accurately as possible as is:

No. It would be easier to limp wrist it not harder as you surmised. "Limp wristing" is the term used to describe not holding the gun firmly in place enough so the slide can function properly.

The delayed blowback needs the interaction between the two parts to function properly. One moves (the slide) and one is immobile (the frame). Limp wristing allows the frame to move thus interfering with the relative movement of the slide. Enough movement (limp wristing) and the ejection of the spent round or chambering of the new round will not occur.

The lighter the gun -- the more felt recoil there is
The smaller the gun -- the harder it is to grip firmly.

Both of these occurring either separately or together increases the chances of limp wristing.

There will be no "limp wristing" phenomena with a firm grip on a compact gun that does not allow it to move. That's why I didn't agree with the premise of your question. There is no direct connection but there is a causal relationship.
 

· Wyoming
Joined
·
4,304 Posts
The term "limp Wrist" is also associated with a habit. The habit in this case is the shooter relaxing as the trigger breaks. This causes the muzzle to drop and shoot? Wherever. Have an experienced handgunner observe your shooting stance and follow through. :wink:
 

· AZHerper
Joined
·
6,352 Posts
You tried to post a file that is on your local F: drive. It made it to the post on your computer because you have access to the file. It didn't make it to the forum because it doesn't have access to the file and you don't want that.
You're so right! Of course it worked great on my computer but the F: drive is there. Anyway, I have the source in HTML and javascript but I think I'll just forget it. I don't think too many people would be that interested. The program also computes recoil momentum but only one of the variants that I wrote prints it. One probably has a bit of of a problem visualizing the sensation of something dimensioned as mass times velocity (M*V) or foot pounds (pound-feet) per second. However, per Newtons third law, every action has an equal and opposite reaction and the momentum of the bullet and gases exactly equals the momentum imparted to the gun an shooter. Just be thankful that the bullet energy and recoil energy don't equate. That would translate to lethal recoil from anything more violent than a BB gun. :smile5:
 

· Registered
Joined
·
22,088 Posts
I noticed in my desert shooting trips that after a set count of expended rounds with a .45 auto - usually 300 to 250 rounds - I would begin to experience an occasional "stove-pipe" or failure to "chamber". From experience I knew "shooting fatigue" was setting in, and if I wanted to continue shooting and eliminate these glitches, I needed to be more aware of my offering resistance to the firearm recoil than acting like a shock absorber, aka "limp wristing".

Limp wristing has its detrimental effects on revolver shooting as well. This is a relaxing of the wrist in anticipation of recoil and it totally eliminates "follow through" at the time if hammer fall.
 

· Super Moderator
Joined
·
16,629 Posts
The guy who taught me to shoot a pistol was an Army Ordinance Officer and shot on the Army Pistol team. That instruction called for the middle, ring and little fingers of the gripping hand wrapped securely around the grip. The rear of the grip was held securely in the web of the hand (activating the safety) and the thumb "rested" along side the action below the line of the slide. I was not to ever grip with the thumb. On the first 1911 I shot extensive I experienced some stove piping. this was due to a weak spring and not a relaxed grip.

If I just had to touch the weapon with my off hand I could set my palm directly under the mag well.

I don't know the rightness or wrongness of this method but I can hit what I'm aiming at.

A 1911 in 45 ACP is somewhat unforgiving of those who will not hold on to the damn thing.

Alan
 
1 - 18 of 18 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top