[winchester25]

I've been in the market for a good pump action 12 gauge for a while and I've narrowed my choices to 3. I will be buying the field version of each of the guns because I prefer a wooden stock. My first selection is a the winchester SXP I like the low recoil and that the pump slides back when you shoot so yon just have to push forward and also as my name implies I'm a huge fan of winchester. My next choice is a Remington model 870 I like the quality of these guns and the historical significance of it and it being used by military and police personnel. Third and final choice is the mossberg model 500 I like it for the military and police use and like the price and in Canada (where I live) it is the cheaper choice. I'm personally thinking SXP but looking for suggestions and advice.

 

[deputy]

don't know much about that particular model winchester.......

the 870 and the 500......both older established models with proven track records and production probably in the millions. Huge cottage industry for after-market parts/accessories. Numerous choices in accessory barrel configurations. after-market stock options.

870 is a very easy gun to field strip for cleaning. The Steel receiver is superior over an aluminum receiver for scratch resistence/abuse. 870 has one heck of a record over the decades for hunting and law enforcement usage.

500 is a good gun. cost effective and less expensive barrels. I have never short stroked a 500,,,,,,,,can't say that about the 870. Weak point is the plastic safety button which i have seen them broken or cracked from abuse. I use a steel aftermarket replacement button myself.

handle the guns if possible and see what feels, points, and fits best for yourself.

 

[Elapid]

In a dire situation my 870 is my go to gauge, I have the Marine Magnum with synthetic stock, maybe not the prettiest but could easily be the toughest.

 

[Northtidesix]

I own many SxS shotguns. I have four pump action shotguns Winchester Model 12, 2-12ga,1- 16ga. and 1-20ga. They are all steel and wood construction. I tried in my early years to wear them out. I couldn't. I would not even try to guess how many thousands of shells I have fired through these guns. I recently bought my latest Model 12 from a seller on Gun Broker it was made in 1915. A photo is posted on Gun Related Pictures. Shoots great.

 

[olhippy]

Flip a coin--all great shotguns. I have a 500 and 870 but have shot the Win many times---I like it.

 

[winchester25]

Ive decided to go with the winchester sxp I was bred to love them and ill just have to get one! Thanks everyone for the advice!