National Gun Forum banner

Chinese National Pleads Guilty To US Birthright Citizenship Tourism Scam

439 Views 3 Replies 4 Participants Last post by  LRDGCO
Timothy Meads
Oct 01, 2019

At this point in our ever-ending news cycle, this story may seem outdated but it is important to keep an eye on for several reasons -- chief among them examining the various ways Open Borders Inc. benefits from America's immigration policy. On September 17, the Department of Justice announced that a Chinese Foreign national plead guilty to running a birthright citizenship scam here in the United States. What does that mean? In short, Chinese citizens would pay thousands of dollars to Dongyuan Li, a 41-year-old woman from California, to arrange a trip to the US for pregnant wives of wealthy and government employees. These women would be trained on how to lie to U.S. authorities and then overstay their approved visit so that they could give birth here and secure U.S. citizenship for their children.

Here are details for the case, emphasis added:

Li admitted in her plea agreement that, from 2013 until March 2015, she operated a birth tourism company in Irvine and in China called You Win USA Vacation Services Corp. You Win would assist pregnant foreign nationals — typically from China — to travel to and remain in the United States to give birth so their children would receive birthright U.S. citizenship, according to the plea agreement.

According to a January 2019 federal grand jury indictment against Li, You Win advertised that it had served more than 500 Chinese birth tourism customers seeking U.S. birthright citizenship for their children. The indictment details that Li used 20 apartments in Irvine, charged each customer between $40,000 and $80,000, and she received $3 million in international wire transfers from China in two years.

Some You Win customers coached by the company made false statements on their visa applications and to U.S. immigration officials, Li’s plea agreement states. Li also admitted that the customers were advised on how to pass the U.S. Consulate interview in China, including by falsely stating that they were going to stay in the United States for only two weeks, when in reality, they planned to stay for up to three months to give birth.​

The DOJ confirmed that this was just one case out of many in the "birth tourism industry." Why is this so bad? Michelle Malkin, author of Open Borders Inc., broke it down for Townhall. In short, foreign nationals are lying to the U.S. government about their true intent, profiting off vulnerable mothers, and subverting U.S. immigration law.

"The profiteers of Open Borders Inc. come in all shapes, sizes, and nationalities. The birthright citizenship magnet incentivized this Chinese national to cook up an elaborate scheme involving 500 pregnant foreigners who repeatedly lied and defrauded our government," Malkin told Townhall. "But keep in mind: This is just one schemer who got caught. Illegal alien anchor baby rackets from all around the world have proliferated for decades. How many more will we tolerate before Congress shuts off the magnet?"

Indeed, this case highlights that human trafficking comes in all forms. America's immigration system needs reform to stop these sorts of crimes, in addition to a wall that stops illegal border crossings.
See less See more
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
We need to get rid of birth right citizenship.
It has been bastardized and is no longer used as its original intent.
After the Civil war, those wonderful democrats did not want the former slaves to vote or have the same rights as American citizens,
So the legislation was passed that if you were born here, you are automatically a citizen.
Only 8 countries in the world have this 7 in South America and the Caribbean, and Canada.
What! Chinese people want to obtain USA citizenship? can not be! China is advertised by the Chinese government as the poster nation for the Glorious Communist Socialist utopia, let us face it, China is the epitome of the "Paradise of the Proletariat"

See less See more
I remember sitting at a dinner party in Dubai in the late 1990s listening to a Palestinian expat lecture me on American imperialism and "unfair support for genocidal Israel". Meanwhile, his wife was in the US giving birth so that their child would have US citizenship. They probably subsequently chain migrated.
1 - 4 of 4 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.